HeyBeauty 2 Pack Eyebrow Pencil with Dual Ends - Black | With 2-in-1 Eyebrow Brush, Waterproof Brow Pencil for Women Makeup, Precise, Long-Lasting, Professional Brow Enhancing Kit

I try to use clean products, and when I ordered this, I must have closed my eyes and ignored the ingredient listing, lol. With that, as of the date of the review, these are the ingredients: C10-18 Triglycerides, Synthetic Wax, Copernicia Cerifera (Camauba) Wax, Rhus Succedanea Fruit Wax, Dimethiconol, Talc, Ceresin, Synthetic Fluorphlogopite, Cera Alba, Suagl'd Stearate, Paraffin, Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil, Stearic Acid, Behen¥| Alcohol, Ethylene/Acrylic Aci Copolymer, Tocopheryl Acetate, Methylparaben, Propylparaben, BHT, Ethyihexylgiycerin Colorant: Cl 77492/ Cl 77499/ CI 77491/ Cl 77891 Honestly, I will finish the product and look for something different. :( I do love the brow pencil, though. I like the dual ends, one being chunkier, which makes it easy to fill in fuller brow areas, and the other end is thin and useful to fill in thinner brow areas. The color works well with my brow color. I use Khaki Coffee. I have olive skin tone and brown (level 5) hair color. It goes on evenly and smoothly and stays put all day. I find this to be a great value for two double-ended brow pencils and a brow brush. The product is made in China. In addition, the package indicates that they passed GMPC Certification, which is Good Manufacturing Practice Certification. According to the AI overview from Google, this is the response: "GMPC is a quality assurance system for cosmetic products. It ensures consistent production and control of cosmetic products according to high standards. GMPC certification involves assessing manufacturing processes, facility hygiene, product testing, and documentation to ensure compliance with regulations." So, depending on how into clean products you are, this may not be for you, but if you follow an 80/20 rule, this is worth considering.

I love these eyebrow pencils, they are super easy to use, they fill in your eyebrows beautifully with plenty of color and if you use them with a brow gel they will stay put the whole day. This will be my go to over any high end brow pencil. They are also super long lasting, in fact I have not worn them out for a whole year. Five stars, I totally recommend

I liked these and have bought them a few times now. Really good product at a decent price

These are absolutely perfect for me! I’ve been using them for the past few years as my brows have become thinner. I have to draw myself brows every morning now and gives me natural looking brows. The color is just right and with a setting spray, it lasts all day.

This is my favorite pencil it goes on just the way I like and lasts all day

I needed an eyebrow pencil on the fly and I thought this was a pretty decent deal for the price. I read a ton of reviews and the overall consensus was that it's a pretty good pencil and most people really like it. I did notice one review stated that not a ton of people in these photos really knew how to do their brows, so she didn't have much to go off of and no shade but, I have to agree and I just need to figure it out for myself. With that being said, I've been doing my brows for at least 2 decades now and, I have my products and techniques down to a science (I have a few different ways of doing them, from natural to bold) but I needed something while I waited for my higher quality products to arrive. Let me also add that I did my brows pretty lazily in these photos because I wasn't going anywhere and I was just testing the product so, this isn't my best work lol Oh and I have very fine/sparse brows so I need a product that will fill them in properly. Quite a few people said that it glided easily and went on smoothly, which it did, on the fine tipped side. When that happens, it's usually because the pencil and/or the skin is either moisturized or oily. In my case, it's a little of both; my skin is hydrated and the pencil is a little oily which causes smudging! This is absolutely NOT a smudge proof pencil, nor is it water proof. That claim should be removed from the description altogether, it's just NOT. Now, on the tapered side, the pencil was rather dry and a bit waxy, which causes tugging and that results in an inconsistent application. It's quite annoying tbh and I feel it's a waste of product and money because I probably won't be using that side very much, if at all. As far as the spoolie and angled brush, I'll give them credit for that. I used the brush to clean up my brows with a bit of concealer. Again, I didn't fully carve them out like I usually do. I used the brush to apply a bit of got2be gel on my brows (I've been using it for a few years now) and I prefer a smaller spoolie with more compact bristles because the gel was just kind of sitting in the crevices which wasted the product. I feel like it would work better for someone with thick brows and that ain't me! Lol My final thought is, in the future, if I'm going to buy a drugstore quality pencil, I'm going to stick with the Maybelline micro pencil that I've been using forever. I hope this helps!

Finally, a brow product that looks good & is easy to apply. I've tried almost every type of brow product (pens, pencils, gels, powders, henna, temp tattoo ink) all with varying amounts of success. These brow pencils apply smoothly & easily, no chunks, and you have the best of both worlds with a wide end to fill in plus a micro point end for hair-like strokes & precision work. No sharpie brows & the color for gray-brown was on point. I usually don’t have an issue with touching my brows so I can’t speak for about whether it's budge proof but the color & shape lasted all day on me. So pleased with this purchase. Hope this was helpful.

Have been using these for years! And I’m obsessed. I will keep on buying them, as I have found nothing I love more!!!