Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer Eyeliner, Highly Pigmented, Long-Wearing, Built-In Smudger, 230, Deep Ocean, 0.01oz

I decided to try the Rimmel London Exaggerate Auto Waterproof Eye Definer in Blackest Black, and I have to say, it was the best decision ever! Right from the first application, the color payoff is fantastic—it’s truly that deep, bold black that I was looking for. It glides on smoothly without any tugging on the eyes, which is a major plus for me.One of my favorite things about this eyeliner is how long it lasts. I wore it for a full day at work, and it stayed put without smudging, even after a long day of meetings and the occasional teary moment from laughing too hard. It's definitely waterproof, which is something I appreciate, especially with the unpredictable weather we have here.The auto twist-up feature is super handy too! No more dull pencil sharpening for me. This double pack is also great—having a backup is always nice! Overall, I highly recommend the Rimmel London Exaggerate Auto Waterproof Eye Definer for anyone looking for a reliable, bold eyeliner that won't budge. It’s been an amazing addition to my makeup routine! I will repurchase this forever!!

My favorite liner, you can line the inner part of your eyelid and it stays!

easy to apply - stays on very well - little smudging

For under 5 bucks, this eyeliner is almost perfect. It lasts as long as a budget-eyeliner should. It glides on easily. It is buildable for a long enough period of time before it starts to "skip"/pull up product. Blendability is good as long as you blend quickly after application.My biggest gripe is the sharpening ability. I do one eye with a wing after sharpening and it is perfect! I got to sharpen the pencil to do the other eye and the tip of the pencil starts breaking up. I think the plastic twist barrel is too thin, causing the warmth from my hands to heat it up to the point the pencil is too soft to sharpen.At the price point, I am not upset. If you don't want to do wings, it is perfect. If you do wings with a stencil, it is perfect. If you do wings more quickly than I do, it is probably fine.

I can actually buy all my cosmetics from Amazon, as the stores no longer carry them! This is my favorite liner been using it for almost ten years. Love it.

New fave eyeliner! Bought this in black first and loved it. Now I have dark blue and this brown, too. It is richly pigmented and very smooth. I’d call it water resistant. Sent my Mom some and she loves it, too! In the pic, I’ve got a neutral/warm color over the lid with some med/dark brown blended on the lateral eyelids. Eyeliner color is the Rich Brown.

The ordering process and service were smooth, so no complaints there. But I was really surprised and disappointed when my eyeliners arrived with no seal or plastic wrap at all. For a makeup product, especially something that goes on your eyes, that’s just not okay.It made me question if they were new or possibly used. On top of that, the tip of one of the eyeliners was broken off as soon as I opened it. Super disappointing.Makeup should always come sealed for safety and peace of mind. I don’t think I’ll be ordering these again unless the packaging is improved.

Wasn't sure it would stay on but it does.. all day