e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof Eye Makeup, Ultra Pigmented, Long Lasting Formula, Charcoal

Finally an eye liner that doesn't make my eyes water! Love it! Easy to apply and lasts all day! Certainly recommend it!

Just what I'd been looking for, for some time. I'm very happy with it: it goes on smoothly and looks good.

I ordered this to replace my clinique quickliner for eyes, as it is becoming a little expensive. The texture is great, colour is intense and for mature eyes it glides on. I line my eyes in the actual lashline for thicker looking lashes and an impact. But this did leave quite alot of fallout under my eyes after an hour. So sadly not a replacement for my Clinique eyeliner.

Very good, stays on

Glides on easily, doesn’t drag, lasted me most of the day. Would like a slightly stronger pigment as it faded to dark grey after a few hours but that’s a small point.

Love this pencil gives me nice brow details and lasts but you don’t get much in there

The best I have tried. Blends really well if done before it "sets" but if left will also last a long time without smudging or melting in the heat. Doesn't break off if pressure used. Gentle on water line odf eye

Worst eyeliner i have ever bought, screw up is to loose and just retracts, also snapped completely off in 2 places even with only the tip visible, absolute rubbish

this went on smooth and washed off nicely. I liked that it is a warm shade of black. I don't think there is enough product in the tube tough.

Adoro alla follia questo tipo di eyeliner! La sua consistenza così cremosa lo rende estremamente facile da utilizzare: si stende che è un piacere e ti lascia tutto il tempo di sfumarlo con precisione, senza fare macchie. Proprio per questa sua texture fantastica, ammetto che lo utilizzo in modo un po' alternativo: lo applico principalmente come se fosse una matita nera, soprattutto sulla rima inferiore dell'occhio, perché riesco a sfumarlo e a lavorarlo infinitamente meglio rispetto alle classiche matite in legno o automatiche. Tenuta pazzesca: Il vero miracolo lo fa all'interno dell'occhio (ma volendo anche sulla rima superiore). Chi usa la matita nera nella rima interna sa che dopo poche ore tende inevitabilmente a sbiadire o a sbavare creando l'effetto "panda". Questo eyeliner cremoso no: una volta fissato, rimane lì, perfetto e super intenso per ore e ore, senza muoversi di un millimetro. Lo straconsiglio!

No issues with purchasing or shipping through Amazon. This is definitely a win and a repurchase for me. If you're interested in my thoughts on this product and how it compares to e.l.f.'s Kohl Eyeliner in the shade Berry Necessary, keep reading. I struggle with eyeliner running and smearing, and since kohl liners are typically designed to smudge, that doesn't exactly work in my favor. I also have slightly oily eyelids due to my skin type. This isn't a flaw specific to e.l.f.'s kohl liners...I have the same issue with many pencil liners, even ones marketed as waterproof. To my surprise, this eyeliner barely smears on me at all. That wasn't even the main selling point, as I'd more or less accepted that most pencil liners would always smudge on me unless they were liquid. What initially caught my attention was the shade Ruby. I also tested the waterproof claim by swatching both Berry Necessary and Ruby on my hand and washing them with regular soap. After about 15 seconds of light rubbing, Berry Necessary was almost completely gone, while Ruby looked practically untouched. I experienced the same results on my eyelids. Several hours after applying Ruby and working an entire shift, it still looked nearly identical to when I first put it on. Better than the panda eyes I typically end up with. What's especially impressive is that it removes easily with micellar water while still standing up to my eyelid oils and a bit of humidity. I love the color of Berry Necessary, but I find that it fades within a few hours. Over time, the pencil also seems to harden, making it more difficult to apply around the eye area. I wanted something with a very similar shade but better longevity, and Ruby delivered exactly that. I was initially worried that Ruby would lean too red and lack the darker dimension that makes a burgundy eyeliner so flattering, but it's exactly what I hoped it would be. Berry Necessary is slightly more purple, while Ruby is slightly more red. However, Ruby is not so red that it looks like a true red eyeliner rather than a burgundy one. I'd estimate it's only about 5% redder than Berry Necessary. For now, I'll use the remainder of my Berry Necessary pencil as a lip liner. Overall, I'm extremely happy with this purchase and glad I decided to take a chance on it! I added some photos of the liner on my eyes and the liners in regular + flash lighting.

Does what it says. Perfect for a cheap price.

Good. Perfect replacement for my used-up retractable eyeliner. No problems.