Naturalizer Womens Michelle Classic High Heel Pump

super cute vintage pump style! so hard to find. good quality materials. comfortable. nicely padded footbed. fit well overall. slipped off my left heel a bit as my left foot is about a half size smaller than my right. (easy to compensate for by adding a bit of wool fiber to the toe area.) fit my right size 9 foot just fine. love the rounded toe. does not pinch and cramp my foot like pointed shoes always do. plenty of room in the toe box for my longer than average toes. loved the shoes! sadly had to return as the height of the heel aggravated my bad knee. otherwise, would have gladly kept and worn them.but my knee hurt terribly after wearing them.

Why did you pick this product vs others?:I love Naturalizer shoesDurability:Tjey last for yearsSize:These were a tad bit loose but wearable Good quality leather and great color.

Very comfy fits true to size

Love these they are so comfy

I’ve desperately needed a comfortable pair of basic black heels that can get me through a work day, and I kept reading that these were great shoes. I loved that they came in so many different sizes, and I ordered my regular size. When I tried them on around the house, my heels began to slide out as I walked. I’ve had this issue before, though it isn’t very common for me. But, no bother, I thought, I’ll try different sizes. So I ordered the same size in a narrow and a half size down. When I tried those, the narrow still had my heel sliding out as I walked. The half size down didn’t slide, and I began to wonder if I’ve just been putting my feet into the wrong size of shoe for my entire adult life. I was a little concerned, though, that they would start to feel too small after some real life wear, not just walking around the house. But, there’s no way to find out but to try, so I did. And sure enough, within the first couple of hours of work, my heel may be staying in place, but the rest of my foot felt like one of Cinderella’s step sisters, trying to stuff a giant foot into a tiny slipper. Having only discovered this once I was out in the real world, there was nothing I could do, these were no longer returnable. So, I then bought a shoe stretcher hoping to solve the problem that way, but, sadly, no. Or maybe my feet are just so scared of all of the pain I have gone through in these things that I just look at them and my feet start to swell. Either way, these simply do not fit. I have to assume that I really am the size I had thought and purchased from the start, but the issue is actually in the fit of the heel of the correctly sized shoe.Unfortunately, it took a large waste of money to figure that out. I have no problem investing in a good pair of shoes to get me through the day with minimal pain, but as a single parent, and a public sector employee at that, I don’t exactly have the spare cash to be throwing around on ill-fitting shoes that will likely become nothing more than an overpriced dog chew toy.I purchased these through Amazon’s Try Before You Buy program, but the real problem is that once you wear them on anything that shows signs of wear, aka for more than just 30 minutes barely walking on carpet, you can’t return them. How are you supposed to know that a shoe will fit properly and well if you can’t actually wear it around to find out? I guess that’s a risk all high heel wearers take, but Naturalizer has always had a reputation for well-fitting, comfortable heels, and in fact, my very first pair of heels were light blue leather ones that my grandmother purchased from Naturalizer back in 1995. They were so comfortable that I wore them constantly, always feeling more sophisticated than all of the other 11-year-olds in the neighborhood. Those may have been a hit, but my adult Naturalizers are nothing more than a huge, expensive miss.

Unlike the previous pair of the same Naturalizers, the leather on this new pair looks dull and doesn't feel the same. Briefly tried them on, and the inside is not as comfortable as the pair only worn a couple of times. Had to put them side-by-side to be sure. Maybe, this pair was an outlier. I'll return these and try again later hoping to come up with the same quality as the previous pair.

Excellent quality. True to size. Very comfortable.

These are the most comfortable high heels I have ever owned! I have them in 3 colors.