e.l.f. Lash XTNDR Mascara, Long-Lasting & Buildable For The Look Of Lash Extensions, Clump & Flake Free, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Soft Black

I can't rate this mascara more highly. :) I have a tendency toward extreme smudging with mascara so when I saw that this is a 'tubing' formula, I was excited to give it a try. I have zero regrets! With the tubing formula, the mascara coats your lashes in tiny tubes rather than actual pigment as regular mascaras would do. As a result, if I have hayfever and my eyes water (or it's a sad occasion), I can simply dab away away tubing that flakes off, no smudging at all. I'd also like to comment on just how long my lashes look when using this. While my lashes are naturally long, this mascara looks far better than false lashes for the sheer amount of intensity, volume and length it creates. I can't recommend this highly enough. :)

Best mascara I’ve used. I have oily skin and fairly long eyelashes, the two combined means I used to always have black smudges under my eyes. I’ve tried expensive mascaras that are supposed to be smudge proof or suitable for oily skin but I got the same panda look from all of them. I’d have to check my make up constantly to make sure the panda hadn’t returned or that I didn’t have mascara goop in the corner of my eyes. Waterproof mascara was no good either due to wearing contacts. Then, while looking online for the next one to try, I found a review for this one and I’m so glad I did. It’s the best mascara I’ve ever had. It does not budge during the day, no more panda eyes, no more mascara goop and at the end of the day it looks as fresh as it did when I put it on. Plus it’s so easy to remove and when it’s removed your eyelashes are completely mascara free, no more waking up with mascara residue in the morning. I can’t recommend it enough and it’s a great price

This mascara certainly gives a bit of drama! Lovely deep black that gives a lot of definition and makes lashes look longer. It loses a point as it does need a bit of attention to ensure it does not clump. I found that an eyelash primer underneath helps this problem. The price point is reasonable. Needs a good eye make up remover to get it off but if you are looking for something that gives longer lashes and you don't mind applying carefully and possibly using a primer this mascara is a great option. I would probably buy again but I like to swap out my mascara choices regularly. Seems to have lasted well so far.

I've bought so many mascaras over the years - both 'drug store' and designer brands - but this mascara is honestly the best I've ever tried. I cannot believe how inexpensive it is for the quality! Although the design of the packaging/the container is fairly cheap looking and mediocre, the design of the brush and the actual mascara is first-rate. The brush is long and thin. Every single lash is separated and coated, allowing both (extreme) lengthening and gentle curling. It doesn't clump and it looks very natural. Then there is the fact it's a tubing mascara, so it doesn't run or smudge - I'm not sure why, but the moment I turned 40 my mascara started to run and smudge, but this stays put and is easy to remove with a cleansing cloth and water. Finally, and most importantly to me, elf products are all vegan - so completely cruelty-free (and that includes not using ingredients from, or trading with, countries that mandate animal testing). Many beauty brands may be cruelty-free in your own country, but engage in cruel animal testing practices in other countries (such as China), so going for a product labelled as 'vegan' is the only way to be sure. You can rest easy with elf products that you will not be funding animal cruelty. This is the holy grail of mascaras - buy it, you won't regret it.

Nice basic mascara, won’t blow you away, but gives a bit of length and definition. Wears comfortably- my favourite thing about it is that it’s a tubing mascara, so it removes super easily just with a bit of water. No panda eyes or mascara goo left in your eyes after you’ve cleansed!

Ohhh yeah baby this is my new mascara 🛐🙏🏻 perfect if you’re wanting very long eyelashes but not too much volume. I’ve used maybelline sky high for years but found it looked too heavy on me and took forever to apply if I wanted it to look right. This one is fab I can apply it so quick and it tapers off at the end of my eyelashes so well so they don’t go clumpy and look more natural 🕷️ also feels less crunchy than the sky high mascara and is easier to remove

Great mascara, lovely brown colour and the tubing means it doesn’t smudge. Also not flaky like some tubing mascaras I have tried

Great product, stays on all day without smudging and easy to remove.

Ik vond het erg mooi, ik ben er erg van onder de indruk.

No ha habido mascara que me sirva, siempre terminaba como oso panda después de algunas horas de haberme maquillado, pero este tipo de máscara me funcionó increíble.

This has quickly become one of my favorite mascaras—I’ll definitely be repurchasing. Highly recommend if you’re looking for great lashes at a budget-friendly price! 💖

Erfüllt genau die Versprechungen, die der vielgehypte Maybelline Sky High Mascara verspricht, aber nicht hält. Beide Mascaras funktionieren mit der Tubing-Technologie, während dieser hier im Vergleich zum Sky High ein festes Bürstchen hat, mit dem man die Wimpern schön gezielt modellieren kann. So einen reinen marketing-wirksamen Quatsch wie dieses flexible Bürstchen vom Sky High hat dieser Mascara hier überhaupt gar nicht nötig, denn das Ergebnis überzeugt ganz einfach! In knapp 5 min. morgens in 2 - 3 Schichten Wimpern, die WIRKLICH wie Lash Extensions aussehen! Die 3. Schicht brauche ich auch eigentlich nur, um manche der Spitzen noch mal gezielt nachzumodellieren, um dem ganzen noch mal eine Schippe draufzuhauen. Das Ergebnis sieht laaaang, geschwungen, aufgeräumt und gepflegt aus und es übersteht auch mal ein längeres Nickerchen sehr gut! Kein Bröckeln und Verschmieren und abends sieht's noch aus wie frisch getuscht. Dazu das leichte und wimpernschonende Entfernen mit nur etwas warmem Wasser! Perfekt! Als weiteren Vergleich habe ich noch die Catrice Glam & Doll Easy Wash Off probiert. Das Auftragen ist ebenso leicht und schnell gemacht, allerdings reicht mir persönlich das Ergebnis nicht aus. Im Vergleich zur Elf Lash Xtndtr ist es deutlich weniger intensiv - die Wimpern sehen extrem natürlich aus, so als wären sie gar nicht getuscht - selbst nach mehreren Schichten. Man kann einfach keine Intensität damit aufbauen! Mag ich persönlich nicht so. Deshalb: Elf Lash Xtndtr rules 😁

I have spent hundreds of dollars in recent years trying to find a good mascara. In desperation I tried this one. I figured for such a low price it's probably no good, but it can't hurt to try. Being completely honest, it does flake, slightly, but nowhere nearly as much as the more expensive brands I've tried. Otherwise it is perfect. It lengthens nicely, separates lashes, doesn't clump, not one little clump and stays looking nice all day. It washes off with warm water and a wash cloth. And it is a price that I am more than happy to pay!