RIMMEL LONDON Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer - Blackest Black

I love these. They don't smudge and one pencil lasts ages when used every day. Just as good as the more expensive ones like Mac and Bobby Brown

This is the best eyeliner for staying power! Lasted all day, great depth of colour. I brilliant..

Easy application. Long lasting and doesn't irritate. Have used this one for years and wouldn't use any other.

I. was excited after reading the reviews but disappointed I didn't have the same experience Goes on easy but didn't deliver the staying power for me. Everyday it smudges to my under eye even though I only use it on my lid. Don't know if it's because I wear glasses during day that it overheats and wears off. IStill on a quest for a liner that won't move and won't make me have 'pand' eyes at the end of the day. It's a decent liner and worked better than previous ones I've tried. Maybe my eye lids are different to everyone else's!

Doesn't smudge

Great eyeliner. I’ve used it for years. I can’t get on with liquid liner and now that I’m older I need something that doesn’t seep into the skin around my eyes. This is great. It goes on exactly where you put it and no where else.

This product is good if you want smokey eyes, but it unfortunately doesn't stay in place if you want a solid liner. Within a few hours the solid line of eyeliner smudges under the eye and onto the top lid. Leaving "panda eyes".

Good