Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Apply, Smooth Glide, Up to 24 Hour Wear, Onyx, Pack of 2

This is my staple eyeliner. Goes on easily and it really does stay put extremely well. I use the charcoal grey color and it's perfect for my lighter skin and lashes. (Black looks weird on me) I get plenty of uses out of it, I haven't purchased anything else but this in years.

Works great and priced right. Seems to stay on well

I've been using this for years, but now I haven't been able to find it in a store near me. It's easy to apply and last a long time.

I recently tried the Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil (Brown) and it’s become a reliable part of my makeup bag. The pencil glides on smoothly, making it easy to apply even on the first try — no tugging or patchiness. Color payoff is nice: a soft brown that defines my eyes without looking too harsh, great for a natural or everyday look. It stays put fairly well through the day (even through a bit of humidity), though after many hours the color can fade slightly on the waterline. For the price and ease of use, it’s a solid choice — especially if you want a fuss-free waterproof eyeliner for daily wear.

This eyeliner stays on well. I got the dark brown color and it is perfect for giving plenty of definition but not looking harsh. Great product.

I’ve purchased this eyeliner for my grandma five times now, and I’ll keep buying it because she keeps asking me to! She absolutely loves it and doesn’t want to use anything else. It’s clearly a favorite and a product she’s very happy with.

I am a mature lady, and the usual pencil eyeliner tended to pull on my eyelids to the point I no longer wanted to use it. The pencil eyeliner goes on very smoothly and doesn't irritate the eyelids. It lasts all day, and it's waterproof. I think it is a little pricey, however, as it works, it is worth it to me.

Not waterproof and wears off easily.

Es larga duración pero si lo aplicas sobre la línea de agua no dura tanto y tiende a recorrerse por el párpado inferior, hay que retocar lo a las 3 o 4 horas.

Made my eyelids swell up and hurt my eyes.

Fantastic stays in place, just where you put it not everywhere you dont want it! Goes on smoothly and great for the waterline, I have tried 100s and this is up with those costing 3 or 4 times the price!

I’m really happy with this liner. The shade is just that bit less harsh than a black. It goes on and stays on well. I also love that it’s retractable so no need for a sharpener. I’ll buy again.

Buy them online all the time. Better deal, good price great quality.