ColorStay Micro Easy Precision Liquid Liner, 301 Blackout | Waterproof liquid eyeliner with micro felt tip for easy, precise lines. Smudge-proof, longwearing color.

The brown goes on smoothly and looks fantastic if you have a steady hand. Can’t say the same for the black version. It somehow goes everywhere.

This is one of my favorite eyeliners ever. The color is gorgeous and is perfect for blue or green eyes. Sometimes, the formula can separate in the bottle, but it always has worked well if I remember to shake it before using it. The applicator is very thin but holds product well, making it easy to draw sharp wings or stay close to the lash line. If you use it every day, the product does go quickly, but it's worth the price you pay for it and more! Easy to use, dries quickly, and non-irritating to the eyes (even if you accidentally get it directly on the eyeball which I don't recommend anyway). I've also never known it to smudge or stay sticky. Love this stuff and I hope it always stays in stock.

I've been on a quest for the perfect liquid eyeliner for many years. This one is not it for me, but I'll share the good and bad things about it from my point of view. I am so happy the tube is designed so the cap doesn't fall off. The shape is still a tube, and similar to mascara which is simple genius, and revolutionary, considering $10-15 eyeliners where the cap falls off in your purse and both ruins your purse and wastes the product. And gets your hands all dirty. So +1 right away for the product container design! The applicator wand tip is a long, thin brush. I prefer a shorter, more precise felt tip (like Almay) but I am able to work with this even though I have to go over the lines multiple times for the width I want, increasing odds for errors. I like dark brown. This brown is lighter brown with some subtle metal flake or glitter in it. I don't like that. As someone in their 40s, I'm not looking to wear glitter in my eyeliner. There is enough glitter in the eyeshadow I wear and I didn't expect it. The full line itself also looks to me like it puffs a little bit when it dries, but if you touch it, it is still flat. It's the look, at least on my eyes. It does stay more than 24 hours. So if you like it, you've got it! I also like that it does not smudge if you accidentally wipe your eyes. This product is not for me, but I still recommend it. It did not irritate my sensitive eyes.

So I ordered this because I have hooded eyes but love the look of liner and read that my eye color would pop with burgundy colors. I was so excited but the eyeliner that arrived was Whitish pink and like glue. I figured I had received a faulty eyeliner so put in a return for a replacement. Then I read the negative reviews and realized I'd probably be returning both so waited until I got the replacement. I swatched the new one and it's perfect!!! Exactly what I had expected. So it is just a some are defective issue. I recommend returning and getting a replacement if the same happens to you because the color is amazing. I did a quick side by side swatch to share. The top is obviously the defective one and is sticky even after drying, the good one dried perfect with no sticky or flaking.

I was looking for something to replace my L’Oreal cause I have a L’Oreal one that they have stopped making, and it is good the colors great I haven’t had any issues with it but again I’ve only tried it a couple times because it’s brand new to me

This product is not as expected as far as the color. From the name (What The Fudge) and the picture, I expected at least a medium coppery brown, if not darker. There are no other brown selections shown. I like the applicator as well as the longevity, but the color is a vibrant coppery red that I wouldn’t think would be flattering to anyone, especially me. I would recommend the product in other colors perhaps, but definitely not this one.

Sadly this looks nothing like the images. The color is a soft pink basically no pigment. Super disappointed. The pic on my skin is after a ton of shaking to see if I could get some pigment lose. Note package was perfectly sealed and not tampered with. Maybe you will have better luck.

I have purchased this eyeliner before, and it is now my favorite - after trying many, many others. Unfortunately, when it was last sent to me, it was defective, with no brown color in it. I asked to return it, but before I could go to the return center, and only a few days after I requested the return, Revlon sent me a new one. I was in perfect condition. I made a mistake assuming that, as it was an inexpensive item and I received a replacement almost immediately, I decided it was not necessary to return the defective one. Just now, I received a notice that Revlon is still waiting for the returned defective product. I am sorry because I threw it away. I cannot return it. I am impressed with Revlon's customer service and did not intend to take advantage of it . Please advise.

La punta es super delgadita, como podrán ver no seca en mate, de hecho en la descripción del producto lo menciona, casi no uso delineador porque tengo párpado encapotado ☹️ pero últimamente he vuelto a usarlos, pedí el tono marrón precisamente para que no sea tan obvio si no delineo bien jeje 😅 la ventaja de tener la punta súper delgada es que en mi caso podré hacer finito el delineado sin batallar con mi párpado 🤷‍♀️ Antes de usarlo hay que agitar (trae un balin dentro) y para abrir o cerrar al girar hace un clic. Primera puesta, veré que tal su duración, en el empaque dice que lo puedes retirar con agua tibia y jabón, así que mientras no talles ahí seguirá, los swatches qué hice en mi brazo estando secos los talle con el dedo en seco y no se quitaron pero humedeci el dedo, volví a tallar y entonces si se quitó, no dejando manchones, sino que se quita como despegandose una fina pelicula. Me gustó el producto, el tono, la punta del pincel, aunque no es mate me agrada como se ve!!!

This eyeliner is simply amazing. The pigmentation is a deep, intense black, and it’s very easy to use because the brush is soft, making it effortless to draw on my eyes. It’s long-lasting and stays on all day without smudging. This is the third eyeliner I’ve bought this year because I love it so much!

Best liner I've tried

Muy bueno, seca rápido y tiene algunos grumos, debe manejarse rápido pero el color es negro mate 10/10

Super soft brown tone for a more subtle eye liner. I do wish it was more darker in brown as you can’t see it all that much. I switch to brown eyeliner as I found black was looking too harsh. Stays on all day. No creasing in the lids. Price is great.