New York 1-Count, Toffee: Super Stay Matte Foundation Full- Coverage Stick For Normal To Oily Skin, Toffee, 0.25 Oz

I’ve been using the Maybelline New York Super Stay Foundation Stick in Toffee, and I’m genuinely impressed. The coverage is fantastic, smooth, buildable, and it evens out my skin tone without feeling heavy or cakey. It glides on effortlessly and blends like a dream, making it perfect for quick touch-ups or full face glam. What I love most is how well it performs on my normal-to-oily skin. It stays put throughout the day, even in humid weather, and doesn’t slide or separate. The finish is natural yet polished, and the shade Toffee matches beautifully with warm undertones. Bonus: the compact size makes it super travel friendly. Whether I’m heading to work or packing for a trip, this stick is always in my bag. Highly recommend for anyone looking for reliable coverage and a fuss-free application.

I have Maybelline Fit Me in the matte liquid. I have dark skin (I’m African American). The matte liquid worked great. I think I’m shade 368 which is Deep Golden. So I figure I would try the Toffee because Mocha looked too dark and Toffee I thought would work. Wrong. My daughter is mixed and it matches her skin about perfect compared to mine. That’s how light it is. So then I decided to go on the Ulta website and saw Warm Coconut which I thought would be good for me since Coconut in the Fit Me stick form works for my skin tone (as long as I don’t go super heavy with it). But that didn’t work either. So I took it back to Ulta and exchanged it for a couple other things...one thing that wasn’t my shade and another I don’t even use *eye roll*. A woman’s job is never done when it comes to makeup lol. I gave this product a good rating because the product works like it’s supposed to. It goes on creamy and I like the fact that there’s a sponge on the end for blending. Don’t go too hard on the sponge though because it will start to wear pretty easily. I would use the sponge for under the eye and other smaller areas, not for all over the face. You’ll probably blend for a half hour doing that with that little old sponge. I picked the wrong shade, but the product feels good going on and not drying so that’s where my five star review comes from.

Exactly as advertized.

Love the make up

Thank you again for another awesome product. I have a contour color for spring/summer and fall/winter. Maybelline never lets me down. Your products are creamy and blend beautifully. Best part is I have sensitive skin and the products never irritate. Thank you!!