Hill'sNatural Fruity Crunchy Snacks, All Life Stages, Great Taste, Dog Treats, Apples & Oatmeal , 8 oz Bag

They are crunchy and My dog love them.

My dog loves it!

My dog loves the taste of these treats! She has a sensitive stomach and has a tendency to have pancreatitis. She has not had any problems with these treats. They are a nice size, hard and crunchy; which my dog loves. Will purchase again.

My dogs love these treat.

I purchased these dog treats to give to my older dog who has problems processing foods that are high in fats. Unfortunately for me, the treats are difficult to break apart and too big to give to her as is. Because of the oatmeal content, they tend to shatter when I do break them apart, so unless they break in the bag - which they've not done - they are not the best choice for smaller dogs.I do have another dog (medium-sized, 25-pound miniature poodle) who is young, healthy, and likes to chew. He gets these treats and seems to do OK with breaking them apart and eating them.The treats themselves have a donut shape and smell like oatmeal cookies. Dogs medium to large breeds with no dental issues will enjoy these dog cookies and owners will appreciate the quality ingredients and low fat content.

Low fat medium size treat. My miniature schnauzer love these.

I received my first bags of these treats as a Christmas gift from a friend. I have been ordering either the cranberry or apple ones since then. My dogs love these as a little nighttime treat before bed and the ingredients seem a little healthier than other items I buy.

Our dogs love them, however, they are much larger in size than what we prefer for little training treats. Our dogs are giant breeds but with treats this huge, and not all that many in the bag, it's just too expensive for too few treats that don't even break easily (too hard to break apart very well). Think we'll be picking out something different next time that is much smaller and better sized for training.