HEROINE MAKE by KISSME Brown Mascara Waterproof, Waterproof Mascara Volume and Length by Tubing Fiber for Long & Curl Eye Makeup for Women, Natural Lash Look for Sensitive Skin from Japan 1 EA

Amazing true brown mascara! This stuff truly does not budge with water, allergies, or even accidentally rubbing them. Volume and definition are good, lengthening could be a bit better but is not my priority. As some others mentioned, micellar water won’t remove this BUT someone else recommended ponds cold cream makeup remover which is a lot cheaper than this brands own remover. It works great for me, even with sensitive eyes

I've been getting more and more into no makeup-makeup looks, and I feel like this brown mascara helps so much with that. I have your typical straight/downward Asian lashes, and this being waterproof helps with the curl, though I think what really makes it stand out for me is that it does not clump, which also helps it really look natural but still lengthening and volumizing! It isn't the easiest to remove, but that can be said about any waterproof mascara I've tried. Oil-based cleansers/makeup removers are your friend here.

I have mostly given up on mascara, especially when I am working. It typically ends up everywhere around my eyes rather than staying on my lashes. Finding this mascara has been so great because when bare, my lashes are so pale they are mostly invisible. The mascara stays on all through my shift and the brown colour doesn’t contrast too harshly with my skin. It does require a good eye makeup remover to get it off. Face wash alone won’t work.

This mascara is great for blondes and red heads. It’s looks very natural and it’s a bit difficult to remove so it lasts! lol

Best mascara I've ever used. It has great lift and stays on all day without settling under my eyes. It's definitely waterproof too. The mascara remover is a MUST since its so gentle. The eyeliner has so much potential to be good, but it dries out so quickly that I just don't know if I can justify buying it all the time.

Color was lovely, but the wand shape led to so many clumps (even after wiping off some of the excess product)! It's waterproof for sure, and the color is wonderful. But on the lashes it was so so clumpy.

I've been looking for a tubing mascara in a natural brown shade with a smaller curved brush (that didn't cost $30+), and this one was highly recommended in a Reddit makeup community! This one is perfect. It applies easily without clumping because the brush isn’t overloaded with product, and it doesn't dry too quickly, so I can use my spoolie to comb it through. It really lengthens, separates and curls! The curved brush is the perfect size, and I like the plastic bristles because they're just flexible enough. It lasts ALL DAY with zero flaking or smudging, but I do have to use a cleansing balm to remove it because it really has staying power. I LOVE it, and I actually just bought another 2-pack for the Prime days deal!

This product is difficult to wash off. I washed my face 4 times with make up remover & specifically targeted my eyes. Original formula made my lashes kinda chunky & heavy so I added a bit of oil & its still hard to wash off.

You can not see my lashes without mascara, I used to get brown lash extensions, classic so nothing crazy and this mascara makes it look like I have the falses on, it lasts! Dries quick and it a bee otch to take off, I use lash glue remover but the company sells the remover too so I’m just being cheap and not getting it. The brown is stunning. Zero complaints will 100% but again

I have searched the world for a good brown mascara that doesn’t smudge. This is the best brown shade color , very natural doesn’t clump and doesn’t smudge! This is awesome you wont regret it! Delivery is fast too. Please keep this in stock I will definitely buy it every month!

I've got super sensitive eyes and this is one of the few products that doesn't trigger a flare up. Looks amazing to.

Never flakes off, my favourite mascara, no mess

The colour and applied look are fantastic. Be warned though that it does not come off easily!!! You need a really good eye makeup remover to get it off, and even then it’s a bit of a struggle. My eyes also tend to get irritated because it makes my lashes quite stiff, I think it’s a feature of it being so permanent. Overall I would NOT recommend this for every day wear for your eyelash health. However, it is great if you want a true brown that is not going to budge, flake or smudge no matter what.