American Apparel Men's Fisherman's Long-Sleeve Pullover Knit Sweater

short answer: material felt great (but not for full price, more like 40 bucks at most), but I would say size up for mens, normal size for womens (for a slightly baggy fit like in the model photos).Long answer: The material of the sweater is great- definitely not 50-60 dollars great, but sometimes you can catch it on sale for 35ish (what I got it for) and i think it's worth that price. Smooth, knit material that's not too thick like a heavy blanket, but also not too thin to where it feels like you got scammed- it'll keep you warm in the cooler months (40-60 degrees F), but don't expect it to be great in a blizzard is what i'm trying to say. The main issue I have with the sweater is the sizing! I'm 5 ft 8 in., 170 lbs (so i have a tiny bit of gut hanging out), and my usual size is a medium, so I figured that if i got a medium, it would have a nice, slightly baggy fit like in the model photos. When i tried it on, the sleeves fit okay but the length/width was really weird- it came down to right where my waistline was, and was more form-fitting than i had expected. Great fit for women, but for men I would definitely advise you to size up 1 (or even 2 if you like baggier sweaters) sizes from what you normally get. Hope my review helps!

Fit great, size large for a 5’7 150lb male! As expected the material can lose form quite easy but it honestly looks good and just “works” with this particular aesthetic. The color matches photos near perfectly. I would suggest being mindful not to catch the sweater in a zipper since it’s knitted, I did so the first day I wore it but fixed it by carefully pulling the pieces around it and getting it back in place. I bought it on black Friday deal for $34 and I feel like that price was a bit more justified of the quality than the original price.

This sweater fits poorly. While the sleeves are long enough, it is very short in the torso or body. It barely reaches to the top of my pants. And I have a short torso. In contrast, a sweater I got from the gap is 6 inches longer in the torso. The fabric is nice. It's very warm. But the dimensions are ridiculous.

I couldn’t decide between an extra-small and a small, so I ordered them both. Love the way the extra-small fits. The small was just a little too baggy for my taste. I’m usually a small/medium in women’s clothing.

It would’ve fit based off the arm length and shoulder width but the stomach was essentially a crop top. And I by no means have a long torso.

My grandson loves the sweater. It is well made and looks very nice.

Great sweater, men size up

Size is good, but the color is different than expected.

These are not authentic American Apparel clothes; the tag says that they are made in China. The quality is not worth the price that you're paying. It looks like something you could get from Uniqlo for a fraction of the cost.