Nuts ‘N More Cookie Butter Peanut Butter Spread - High Protein, Low Carb, Low Sugar, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, All-Natural Nut Butter Snack (15oz Jar)

I had very high expectations for this stuff and I was hoping that I could make it a daily addition to my shakes, but like others have said, the new formula is garbage... The texture is very gritty and seems as though they mixed it with some extremely cheap whey protein. I really had hoped for more, but this thing went into the trash as soon as I got it. 8/11/16 **Update** I was contacted by Nuts 'N More in regards to my review and they offered to send me a new shipment of their new formula. The new formula was 100% better than the previous version and has become a daily addition to my morning shake. When the order arrived I noticed that some separation had occurred because the top portion was VERY salty, but a good stir quickly changed things. The taste is such a drastic difference in comparison to their old formula. Less gritty and tastes like it was made with higher quality protein and actually tastes how I felt cookie butter should taste. I greatly appreciate them reaching out to me and I believe that is how customer service should be handled by every company. Thank you Nuts 'N More team. 2/22/17 **Update** Since my review is getting more attention than I had anticipated I thought I would provide another update on this stuff. I am still using this on a near every day basis. I've found that adding a spoonful to a protein shake or a bowl of oatmeal is a great way add some additional protein and a wonderful flavor. I've tried a few of their other flavors and still have not found one that I liked more than the cookie butter.

As someone who has purchased and consumed this product for the last 2-3 years, I must say that it is delicious and nutritious. I love peanut butter and PB flavored almost everything. This cookie butter is the best of the flavors, in my opinion, however if you like Nutella, I would recommend their hazelnut chocolate flavor, it’s Devine. I keep this in my pantry and have mini anxiety attacks when I notice it getting close to empty. It’s packed full of protein and easier to spread than most peanut butter. Additionally, it pairs well with apple slices, French toast, protein pancakes, regular toast, and almost anything you can think of. Even decatant by itself on a spoon. I wouldn’t waste putting it in a shake since that would take away and dilute the taste of this awesome spread. Just mix well when first opening it. Don’t hesitate to try it, you’ll thank me!

I bought the cookie butter flavor because I'm a big fan of Biscoff spread, even thought I knew this one wasn't going to be exactly the same. It certainly tastes nice (kind of slightly warm, slightly spiced peanut butter) and I was happy to see it has a bit of protein and fiber and was also pretty low in sugar. Definitely does not taste like the full-sugar Biscoff butter, so don't buy this product expecting it to be a replica flavor-wise or texture-wise. But I guess this was not the flavor that made me go "OMG I need to keep buying this forevar!" I'll certainly eat it and it's by no means bad, but I just may not make a repeat purchase, especially for $13+ for such a small jar (I get why, I understand low-sugar/protein/fiber/diet products tend to be more expensive). I kind of wish I could get a bunch of sample packets of different flavors to try before committing to purchasing a whole jar. I do love how smooth and spreadable it is, and after it had been exposed to the inside of my warm car for a bit, it was practically liquid and I'd be lying if I said I did not consider taking a shot of it right from the jar and consuming my entire daily allotment of calories in one mouthful. It was tasty, but I don't think it's going to be a regular purchase for me. But it's a different and somewhat more nutritionally sound alternative to everyday peanut butter, so if you're looking to just add a little variety to your pantry, it's at least worth a try, I think.

I have enjoyed almost every flavor so far except my most recent purchase of the cookie butter flavor. It tastes like off brand stale christmas. The cinnamon is there but the cookie part most definitely is not. And the return window closed two days prior to opening. The cookies and cream one on the other hand is delicious. Hazelnut blondie 6/10.

Being a Trader Joe's cookie butter fanatic is hard for me because I will literally eat the jar in one day. Just give me a spoon. A couple months ago, I started really cleaning up my diet and upping my protein intake and discovered these protein nut butters that are all over social media. Buff Bake, nuts n' more, etc. I happened to stumble on this flavor on Amazon (can't find it in stores yet) and thought there's no way this will taste like cookie butter, but let's give it a try. You guys... This stuff is absolutely delicious and it tastes like cookie butter. Some people have commented that its runny but if you mix it up really well it's not THAT runny. I put it on toast and rice cakes and it's perfectly fine - definitely not dripping all over the place. Also, people have commented on the texture saying that it's gritty. To me, it's not that gritty at all, and the little grittiness it does have makes it that much more delicious. I thought this would be a great healthy alternative to cookie butter, but I end up just spooning this out of the jar all night too. Sigh. At least this nut butter has added protein and not as much sugar. Highly recommend.

I was so hoping to find a healthier alternative to cookie butter since it's one of my favorite things. Unfortunately this product fell short. For one, it separates so quickly you can barely spread some before it's separated again. But the main issue is it doesn't taste like cookie butter. It tastes like sweetened peanut butter. Most cookie butters have a good spiced flavor but I didn't really taste any spices in this. Won't purchase again personally, I'd rather just eat small amounts of cookie butter and get protein from other sources.

I love nuts n more in general. Their salted caramel and Pumpkin spice is my fav and now Cookie Butter is up there on the list. If you are not familiar with nuts n more product there is decent amount of product separation for most of their nuts butters but mixing it is worth it and I do not mind and just consider it a good forearm workout. Cookie Butter however had no product separation perhaps bc its a limited edition flavor. This flavor is also much THICKER consistency than their other flavors which I LOVED. I am not a lover of trader joes Cookie Butter however I have had it, this does not really taste like that which I personally was happy about. This has faint gingerbread cookie, cinnamon and nutmeg flavors that made it an empty container before the other flavors I had. The price is up there but I paid it because I could not find this flavor in stores locally. For my Summer body, I hope the price stays high; for my happiness I hope the price goes down lol. jk this fits my macros most days.

I've eaten a lot of high protein peanut butter, including most flavors of Nuts N' More, and this is one of the best flavors I've tasted. I'm not sure if it's my absolute favorite (Toffee Crunch, Chocolate Peanut, and Pumpkin Spice are also good), but it's up there. Only thing that's a little disappointing is that it completely hardens in the refrigerator. The Toffee Crunch, Pumpkin Spice, and Chocolate Peanut stay much softer in the refrigerator. It has a bit of a cinnamon taste, but I think it works great.