WHITE MOUNTAIN Carly Signature Comfort-Molded Footbed Sandal

I bought these thinking that I would wear them occasionally when flip flops weren't appropriate in the summer time - but I haven't taken them off since I got them.Because there are only whole sizes I elected to size down based on other reviews and they fit with no room to spare.Let's hope my feet don't swell or change for any reason!But they aren't too small - they're perfect.I read some other reviews that they started to fall apart but I literally wore mine in a river and all it did was stretch the leather straps the slightest bit so they are even more comfortable now. The perfect worn in feel!They look like a much more expensive brand.Though I don't consider it to be a downside, the color is less Navy and more Cobalt. Not quite Royal, but its certainly not a dark blue. And they don't look dirty at all. Maybe I got sent the wrong color but I'm really, really pleased with my purchase.**6/14/15**As I've worn these over the last year, I can say they've held up with surprising strength in my opinion. I've worn them all over - from hiking mountains, to playing in rivers and even wearing to work. After some time the glued on faux leather foot bed liner started to bunch and get gross, but I ripped it out and have no issues since. The rubber sole on the right foot did give out and I had to super glue back together after tripping over the sole several times. Easy fix. My only true and honest complaint is that they stink! Holy lord they stink and make my feet smell just about as bad. I'd buy them again in a heartbeat, but I'm pinteresting how to take the stink out of leather sandals.***8/9/15 They broke. Finally after over a year of traipsing all over mountains and in rivers with these babies on, the small toe strap on the right foot broke while visiting a nearby hot spring. Luckily I was able to still wear them by tightening the buckle, but I likely wont be wearing them anywhere but around the house. I've worn these babies nearly every possible day I could in the last year and am now looking to buy another pair because I think they're well worth the money!!!!*

This is my staple footwear. More than 10 years ago I first bought these, don't remember where or even what brand it was at that point, and I fell in love. I typically hate flip-flops that have the toe thong thing but for some reason these ones just fit right and it doesn't bother me at all. It holds my big toe snug from the sides rather than cutting back into the crease. Eventually (more than a year of heavy wear) I had to retire my beloved sandals. First the soft cover on the top (what the bottom of your foot rests on) peeled off, then eventually the leather at the toe thong gave way. I tried a different sandal and hated it, then found these ones again. And again, and again, and again. I think I'm on my 5th pair. I even bought an extra pair in a different size when I was pregnant with my son because theywere much nicer to my swollen feet than closed shoes. One time a few years in they discontinued them and I was heartbroken until one fateful night when I found them online listed as a new brand - White Mt. I may have cried tears of joy when they arrived and were indeed the same ones as before. Sorely tempted to buy extra pairs for the future in case they are discontinued again!Positives:-Most comfortable sandals I have ever found, ever-Great for casual wear but also look nice enough for semi-dressy-Adjustable strap close to ankle ensures a nice fit without too much flop-Toe strap does not dig into foot like other sandals doNegatives:-I wish the cloth covering was a bit more resilient. This is always the first part to go for me. It starts peeling at the corners and the sandal is definitely less comfortable without it. Although I will wear them even without that, until the toe strap leather eventually wears throughPlease never stop making these!!

I want to give this a lower review because the toe thong is weirdly placed, but I love the sandal so much, I gave it 4 stars.I wear a women's 12 1/2 which means I had a tough decision to size up, or size down. I sized up and ordered the 13.Pros: adjustable width: I have narrow feet and I can tighten the strap so they fit greatsupportivecute for a Jesus sandal-- or as cute as a Jesus sandal can be.Cons: the toe thong is placed so far back from the toe of the sandal, you'd have to have 2x longer toes to make this not look/fit weird.Since this shoe is 1/2 size too big, I'd expect there to be 1/4" extra space front and back, or maybe even 1/2" in the front.By all accounts, I have long toes, which makes this problem even weirder: the thong is placed so far back on the footbed, there is 3/4" dead space between the end of my toe and the toe of the sandal, and my heal is nearly pushed off the back of the sandal. The only way this would fit properly is if my toes were 3" long? hahahaStill they're cheap enough, they're comfortable enough to wear all day, even with the extra 3/4" in toe, I haven't tripped yet, and I like them enough, I'm keeping them.I'll see if I can edit this later and include a photo....

My third pair. They are cork, so over time they need to be replaced. They are the most comfortable shoe/sandal I have ever had. I wear them year round, as long as I don't need the whole foot or my toes covered. Very durable, very comfortable and easy to put on and off, great arch support. Great value for the money. Never had a blister.

I love these sandals! They are my go-to for warm weather. My feet are wide in the toe box area and have bunions so it can be hard finding shoes/sandals that fit well, but these fit like a charm and are super cute. For what it’s worth, I originally found this brand of sandal at my local TJ Maxx and loved them so much I bought a second pair in a different style through Amazon!

Fits great, and they are very comfortable.