MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounce Jar

This peanut butter and I? We’re in a committed relationship. I've ordered it several times now and even took the plunge into a subscribe-and-save delivery—because why risk running out of something this good? That’s a level of loyalty I usually reserve for coffee and sweatpants. Let’s talk ingredients: they’re clean and minimal, just what you want in a pantry staple. No sneaky palm oil or mystery additives here—just real, organic peanut goodness. It’s the kind of label that makes you feel like you made a responsible adult decision without even trying too hard. Now, fair warning: this peanut butter is very runny. Like, "Did I accidentally buy peanut soup?" kind of runny. But hear me out—it works perfectly for my morning routine. I drizzle it right into my hot oatmeal, and it melts like a dream. No clumps, no stirring tantrums, just creamy, nutty bliss in every bite. If you’re someone who eats peanut butter with a spoon straight from the jar, this might take a little finesse (maybe refrigerate it for a bit). But if you’re using it in smoothies, oatmeal, baking, or anything where spreadability isn't a must, this texture is a feature, not a flaw. The jar is a decent size, though honestly, mine doesn’t last long. Between breakfast, baking, and the occasional midnight “just a taste” spoonful, it goes quick—which is why the auto-delivery subscription was the only logical next step. Final verdict? If you’re into real ingredients, smooth (but not thick) texture, and flavor that actually tastes like roasted peanuts—not sugar, not chemicals—this is the one. Just stir it well, store it wisely, and prepare to wonder how you ever settled for the artificial stuff.

Love this peanut butter! I was torn between this peanut butter, organic Jif, and the Justin’s brand. I ruled out the other two based on ingredients and the nutritional facts. I noticed that MaraNatha’s peanut butter had more protein, less fat, and less carbs compared to the other competitors. The texture was smooth and not grainy. I don’t feel like it produces as many oils at the top like other organic peanut butters, so it is not as watery; however it is pretty liquidy (see video). The main reason I got it was for my smoothies so the liquidy part doesn’t affect me, in fact I think it’s easier to blend for smoothies. I don’t feel like the peanut better was as salty either. Just comparing their ingredients and nutritional facts to other peanut butters was what got me to try MaraNatha peanut butter and I don’t think I’ll go back to Justin’s after this.

This peanut butter is delicious. It’s is more liquidy and I love that for different applications. This is perfect consistency for drizzling over ice cream, oatmeal, granola, yogurt, pancakes, and anything else you can think of. I even love it for making spicy peanut sauce for noodles. It’s versatile. The taste is naturally sweet and it doesn’t separate like other peanut butters. I loved it and although it makes for messy peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, I still purchase it for all of the above mentioned reasons.

It is delicious and creamy ; AND healthy with no chemicals or added sugar.

I'm not sure if this is normal or something happened in production. The taste is excellent and there was absolutely no grit BUT consistency was more like thick soup despite thorough mixing and storing in fridge.

Nice pleasant taste but not as nutty as another brand we're currently buying. The consistency of this product is far too watery, more like a thick smoothie. But I want my peanut butter to stay on the bread and not drip everywhere on the plate, all over my fingers when I am trying to eat. It's a mess... :( After opening it for several days, the consistency becomes a little thicker, like you see in the video. It was worse before. Good consistency if you want to use it for cooking peanut sauce or something. But on breads, I prefer a thick consistency so that it stays on the plate and not drips everywhere or goes all over my fingers.

TASTY--and I appreciate that NO PALM OIL garbage gets sneaked into the jar--but this is the SOUPIEST peanut butter ever. Yes I stirred it. Put it in the freezer overnight? My experience: it's still more like gumbo than peanut butter. I like to make peanut butter logs (with celery stix), but sauce-dripping celery logs are not my java. Might've only been this batch? but I've canceled my subscription. On the hunt for another reasonably priced, ORGANIC PEANUT BUTTER WITH NO TOXIC GROSS PALM OIL...

I ordered this based on all the reviews which said it was runny. I like to drizzle peanut butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Perfect!! The one jar was a bit runnier than the other. The 2nd jar was consistent with other natural peanut butter. Overall, great flavor! I would purchase again.