Marsha's Homemade Premium Quality Buckeyes 50 Count Tub - Net Wt. 1.8 lbs

I used to buy these all the time when I went to the Cracker Barrel restaurant. Now thanks to COVID, they're not as easy to obtain anymore. I ordered from the Marsha website back in the early summer, but the site has since stopped selling directly from the website. I was so happy that Amazon offered these!Since I ordered these in late summer, the temperature was still warm, even here in New England. The chocolate was completely melted off, even with the complimentary ice pack, but I enjoy eating these frozen so it wasn't too big of a deal for me. I don't have pictures anymore, but they didn't look pretty. Luckily this was a gift only for me by me, but it wasn't very giftable.Moral of the story, don't order chocolate for delivery in the warmer temperatures!

As always, excellent tasting, but the candies looked like they had been kicked from the factory all the way here! The price on Amazon is the best I can find, but I would not gift these or put out as special treats for guests. I will buy them again, but only as my personal special treat.

A friend bought these for me and now I hate her for it. Obviously I ordered them and I cannot stop eating them. They are sooooo good! Stop me now!

Very good taste, sweet but not too sweet. Don't know if they are always like that or if they were store or transported in the wrong climate, but the peanut butter filling part was a little dry. Used to Lindt and Fannie Mays which are creamier.

I bought this to be a gift… It came to me totally melted together and not “giftable.” It was packed very poorly and couldn’t have arrived in any respectably edible form. It was slimy, gooey and all of the individual “buckeyes” were stuck together...I am very disappointed in this purchase!

I have made buckeyes at home for years and these are just like mine, only I don't have to do all of the work. My family and I have tried other brands of buckeyes and they weren't nearly as good. Some of them were downright inedible. Marsha's are wonderful and my kids often ask to go to Cracker Barrel just to get these buckeyes. If you are looking for Reese's flavor, these aren't it. These are much higher quality and worth every penny if you want buckeyes, but don't have the time or energy to make your own.

These we perfect in taste and texture. I have no complaints at all. To send or give as a gift maybe not a good idea. Through mailing they get tosseled quite a bit and depending on time of year or temp outside they do melt.

These cost a lot of money for what they are. So the value proposition is low.BUT.These are a luxury item. And as this, they are great. Definitely a quarterly or annual treat, but what a delicious one at that!!