TONYMOLY Panda's Dream Smudge Out Mascara

2022 UpdateHard to believe I've been using this (exclusively!) for 7+ years! I have all the tips and tricks down at this point.- Yes, sometimes the stopper comes out if you pull out the want quickly/hard, but rescrewing (hard) and unscrewing the cap again almost always fixes it.- A few drops of saline continues to be the best way to get the desired consistency if it's a bit dry.- Wiping/scraping off the wand on the inner rim of the tube (where the wand goes into the container) can be helpful once in a while if there's too much product in the bristles.If you have oily skin or watery eyes, don't give up on this mascara! It's 25% less than the similar Clinique option and far better, in my opinion.2018 ReviewI've been using this for about 3 years. Literally no smudging. Which is a miracle! When it gets wet in warm water, it just kind of comes off in black strands. This can be a lifesaver at an important event, because you can simply wipe the black strands away and your whole face isn't ruined. It's my recommended mascara for brides doing their own makeup if they have sensitive eyes, for that reason. Sometimes it will get dry in the tube faster than I'd expect, so I just add a few drops of saline and swish around the wand. Works like a charm!

Easy to apply, doesn’t clump or give spider lashes. Can apply multiple layers and lashes don’t get dry and stiff between applications. Doesn’t dry out and flake (inevitably into your eye).

This is great for a young teen just learning makeup or someone that just wants their lashes darker....no length...no volume....just color....I like it fine....but if you want it to add length or thickness....this isn't for you.

This is my second time ordering this mascara (I owned the length boosting and wanted to try the volumizing) and I was looking forward to it because I love the cute packaging and had no issues with my first one. I read some reviews about it arriving dry, and low and behold, this one was sticky, clumpy, and pretty dry, but salvageable. Since I already had to phone support for another item related issue, I decided to just put a few drops of saline solution in it and hope for the best. This helps to loosen up some of the product, and it works! Hopefully someone reads this and they can try it with theirs to make the best of it, and keep the cute panda.

The packaging is adorable - typical of TonyMolyThis mascara goes on easily and doesn't clump easily. It added length and volume to my lashes that accentuates my eyes in a natural way. It doesn't look fake and it's SUPER easy to use. It doesn't smudge and lasts forever. When you want to remove it water IS NOT enough to remove it however you CAN rub it off your eyelashes with your fingers or a tissue and it'll come off in large almost strips.The one negative I have is it can take a bit to dry and leave "panda eyes' you have to wash off. BUT it is easy to remove so that's something.Overall I'd buy it again, it may become my go to mascara it's so good.

Came a little dry, I just added contact solution and it brought it back to life, works and applies pretty good, stays on well as long as you don't wet it (it is not water proof), you can take it of easily it crumbles as soon as you get it wet, it forms this little crumbs and falls off easily without having to rub a lot or use special makeup removers. Would buy again. Did I mention how cute the container is?

I have oily eyelids, and inevitably end up with dark circles under my eyes after wearing mascara for a few hours. I'm always on a quest to find mascaras that last all day without melting. Tubing mascaras are usually the only kind that lasts all day, but even my favorite—the L'Oreal Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara—ends up flaking. This mascara, so far, has made its way to number one on my list. It adds a great amount of definition to the lashes, and *does* *not* *smudge*. It's also harder to remove, but that's definitely a price I'm willing to pay to not have panda eyes by noon.

I have tried so many mascaras, and they’ve all hurt my eyes. This one doesn’t so I’m pleased.